Transphobia is a Threat to all who Seek Equality

My weekly Comment article in the daily Plymouth Herald (22.4.25), opposing the Supreme Court (little new there) but feeling quite inadequate in expressing the pain and fear the Court cast over the Trans+ community, with shades of 51st State and an escalation of the ideological far-Right “anti-Woke” propaganda permeating everything and everywhere. How any socialist can condone any oppression of any minority is unfathomable. The contorted argument that oppressing Trans-women strengthens the rights of cis women is unconscionable. That socialists have to be Tribunes of the Oppressed at all times is unquestionable. Trans+ Rights Now!

The published article:

Women are still oppressed. On a global level, women suffer systemic abuse as second-to-fifth-class citizens or slaves, their burden of service denying choice, autonomy or agency. In Britain one-in-four women will experience an average of six-years of domestic abuse, with 2 women being killed by their partners or close relatives each week, sexual abuse overwhelmingly residing inside the family.
In the workplace, women are still not assured of equal pay and the low-pay across all care jobs is excused by the absurd caricature of the female sex as delicate and gentle, unfit for managerial roles and decision-making.
Women’s oppression is systemic, society maintaining values that demand men are outward, active and physical whilst women should be domesticated, passive and emotional. These absurd stereotypes damage us all and have long been challenged by feminists and disproved by our social experiences. Non-binary and Trans-people have always existed across all societies through all the ages.
The Supreme Court decision to decree that we are all defined by our birth genitalia is a serious set-back to women’s liberation from oppression. To limit sex-based protection to only those born “female” is an absolutist statement that denies the variance of biological characteristics in our species. It defies science. It is a ratcheting-up of State oppression not only of a small minority of humanity but all of us.
Any and all oppression limits workers’ rights and divide us one-against-the-other. Trade unionists in well-organised workplaces have long challenged sexism, opposing all oppression and demanding human rights for all. We oppose this legal change which empowers the most bigoted and reactionary beliefs and sentiments, all of which encompass misogyny.
Little wonder that it is the far-Right who have most loudly applauded the judgement, with a sudden outpouring of anti-Trans hatred.
It is a reactionary political judgement, no doubt pushed for by Starmer’s government and unworthy of any independent judiciary, but loudly applauded by right-wing politicians including Farage and Badenock. They stand with Hungary’s far-Right Prime Minister Viktor Orban who enshrined anti-trans and anti-LGBTQ+ constitution alongside Putin’s homophobic laws. They mirror the vicious bigotry of the fascist AfD Party in Germany. They emulate the politics of President Trump seeking to outlaw medical sex-change alongside his crusade against abortion rights.
In essence, the imposition of binary gender identity places women back into the repressive primary status as baby-makers and feeds the power of the male-supremacists. It restricts what control each of us has over our own bodies, not just in how we appear but which of our feelings are legitimate.
Human biology is non-binary. As any biologist will admit, humans have a variety of chromosome classifications: XX, XY, XXY XXYY and all manner of variation which is why, in science, sex isn’t classified as binary. Genitalia at birth can be ambiguous. You can’t have a binary classification system when there are more than two configurations! That’s why Trans-women are women!
Transphobia is a threat to all of us seeking equality and the end to oppression. Look back at the laws and social attitudes against homosexuality in the 1960’s, now recognisable as extreme prejudice. The damning of those of us with gender dysphoria will once again be condemned in time.
In the meantime, this Supreme Court ruling has reduced Trans+ rights in the UK, Trans people now unable to make equal pay claims and excluded from single-sex spaces that confirm their true identity.
Luckily, Trans+ people, trade unionists and most of the socialist left have risen to immediate protest against the ruling with tens of thousands on the streets last Saturday. This debate isn’t over, the fight for universal human rights continues.

Time to mark International Women’s Day!

Friday 8th March is International Women’s Day. Trade unions have celebrated and commemorated the event every year for generations and will do so again this year. That should hardly be surprising given that women constitute the majority of trade union members, highly represented across the public sector in particular. 

International Women’s Day has absolutely nothing to do with cooking, cosmetics and clothing that some events will focus upon, sponsored by Capitalists large and small, and seeing women as consumers not citizens. Such events actively promote the role-segregation and denigration of of women inside this sexist society.

The Day’s authentic celebrations will focus upon the struggles of working class women, starting with the Bryant & May “Matchgirls Strike” of 1888, when teenage young women, today considered children, formed a union for Health & Safety at work, much derided by employers then and now, and much needed still today. It was also a struggle against women’s oppression, for social justice, building the fight for equal rights at work and at home. A woman’s right to vote, to have full representation in society, to have control over their bodies, their finances and for the right to work.

One-hundred-and-thirty-five years later the struggle for women’s liberation continues, here in the UK and across the world. Internationally, the rape and killing of women is accentuated by war and social conflict.

At home, the Age of Austerity, officially blamed upon COVID, war and climate change rather than record Corporate and Banking profits, has produced mass domestic poverty, women suffering the brunt.

Whilst women constitute the majority of trade union members in the UK, trade unions have a chequered history of fighting for women’s rights. The false divide between men and women in the workplace is exploited by employers, portraying women as a threat to jobs, weak and unreliable – ideas not always challenged. There have been bosses campaigns to identify women as a threat to men’s jobs, unchallenged by unions until women themselves organised against prejudice and discrimination, having to educate male trade unionists as well as employers.

The Great Miners Strike of 1984-5, which began 40 years ago this week, was maintained for an entire year only through the determination of the women in miners communities and beyond, active and leading on picket lines and in support groups, and changing the “male culture” of the union in the process.

Yet today, despite a series of major employment laws for equal pay, won by strike action such as the famous women’s strikes at Ford Dagenham, women workers still earn less than 82% of the man’s wage undertaking work of equal value. 

For part-time workers (of whom many are women) the gap rises to around 30 percent. Over her lifetime a woman will earn on average half of what a man will earn, primarily because of the role women still play as primary carers for children – not to mention all the other family members women will often find themselves responsible for, simply because of oppressive social norms. 

Domestic labour is an asset for the employing class, women reproducing and looking after the workforce free of charge. Women’s oppression is essential to ensure high profits, minimising the costs of social provision of welfare, nurseries and care of the elderly.

Little wonder we see the continued media promotion of the backlash against Feminism, orchestrated by the far-Right from the 1990’s onwards, which has seen a rise in workplace sexism and discrimination, including sexual abuse. Much of the gains won from the 1970’s have been eroded. There is a deepening culture of violence against women and girls, institutionally and socially.

More than 80% of all domestic abuse is from men against women in the UK, with one-in-four women experiencing an abusive relationship for an average period of 6 years of their lives (compared with 1 in 18 of men) – that’s over 6 million women experiencing abuse right now, precisely the same statistic as recorded in the early 1970’s. No change. 

Worse still, 68,000 rapes were recorded by Police in 2022-3, half of which are carried out by the woman’s partner or ex-partner and six out of seven rapes perpetrated by someone she knows, with charges brought in just 2.4% of cases, and far fewer convicted. Little wonder that 5 in 6 women who are raped don’t report it, out of lack of faith in the police and legal system. The succession of cases of sexual abuse by police officers, politicians and sportsmen deliver appalling role models.

9 out of ten girls and young women say they’ve experienced sexist name-calling at school, the era of smartphones resulting in “dick pics” and other sexual images being received, unwanted and unsolicited, and causing a common sense of threat, fear and subjugation. 

The backlash against women’s rights is being ramped-up. The misogynist Andrew Tate’s vile internet broadcasts stating that “women are men’s property” is watched by hundreds of millions, influencing the current young generation, his bile being just the tip of a deep iceberg of political male-supremacy rising-up alongside white-supremacy and racism.

Working class men are stupid idiots to denigrate women – our partners, sisters and daughters, friends and workmates. Indeed, the sense of “protection” evoked by male-dominated culture that arouses men to action when their family members are abused, is hypocritically forgotten when putting down women in the workplace with sexist remarks, shielded as “banter”, and the objectification of women’s bodies, dehumanising women and exerting power over women as a source of domination and self-aggrandisement.

In Plymouth we have experienced, all too horrifically, the results of the campaign for male-supremacy, a gunman who expressed misogynistic and homophobic views shooting his mother and four passers-by, shown to have been part of the “intel” movement promoting male domination and the hatred of women.

The International Women’s Day events this Friday should not simply be a celebration, and certainly not any vehicle for reproducing the sexist imagery and Capitalist cultural domination of women as things and products. We need a huge campaign of education and challenge against women’s subjugation and for true women’s liberation.

The sexual division in the working class should not be underestimated as a the obstacle in achieving the class unity that can win decent pay and conditions for everyone. 

It took militancy and collective action to make the gains now at risk if not lost. Any decent working class men – and we exist in our millions – should restate the pledge this week to challenge all aspects of sexism and women’s subjugation, and join with women if they’re fight against oppression. 

Trade Unionists will stand in solidarity with Plymouth’s Women’s Liberation event 12-2pm on Friday at the Sundial, Armada Way.