Tag: human-rights

Transphobia is a Threat to all who Seek Equality

Tony StauntonLeave a comment

My weekly Comment article in the daily Plymouth Herald (22.4.25), opposing the Supreme Court (little new there) but feeling quite inadequate in expressing the pain and fear the Court cast over the Trans+ community, with shades of 51st State and an escalation of the ideological far-Right “anti-Woke” propaganda permeating everything and everywhere. How any socialist can condone any oppression of any minority is unfathomable. The contorted argument that oppressing Trans-women strengthens the rights of cis women is unconscionable. That socialists have to be Tribunes of the Oppressed at all times is unquestionable. Trans+ Rights Now!

The published article:

Women are still oppressed. On a global level, women suffer systemic abuse as second-to-fifth-class citizens or slaves, their burden of service denying choice, autonomy or agency. In Britain one-in-four women will experience an average of six-years of domestic abuse, with 2 women being killed by their partners or close relatives each week, sexual abuse overwhelmingly residing inside the family.
In the workplace, women are still not assured of equal pay and the low-pay across all care jobs is excused by the absurd caricature of the female sex as delicate and gentle, unfit for managerial roles and decision-making.
Women’s oppression is systemic, society maintaining values that demand men are outward, active and physical whilst women should be domesticated, passive and emotional. These absurd stereotypes damage us all and have long been challenged by feminists and disproved by our social experiences. Non-binary and Trans-people have always existed across all societies through all the ages.
The Supreme Court decision to decree that we are all defined by our birth genitalia is a serious set-back to women’s liberation from oppression. To limit sex-based protection to only those born “female” is an absolutist statement that denies the variance of biological characteristics in our species. It defies science. It is a ratcheting-up of State oppression not only of a small minority of humanity but all of us.
Any and all oppression limits workers’ rights and divide us one-against-the-other. Trade unionists in well-organised workplaces have long challenged sexism, opposing all oppression and demanding human rights for all. We oppose this legal change which empowers the most bigoted and reactionary beliefs and sentiments, all of which encompass misogyny.
Little wonder that it is the far-Right who have most loudly applauded the judgement, with a sudden outpouring of anti-Trans hatred.
It is a reactionary political judgement, no doubt pushed for by Starmer’s government and unworthy of any independent judiciary, but loudly applauded by right-wing politicians including Farage and Badenock. They stand with Hungary’s far-Right Prime Minister Viktor Orban who enshrined anti-trans and anti-LGBTQ+ constitution alongside Putin’s homophobic laws. They mirror the vicious bigotry of the fascist AfD Party in Germany. They emulate the politics of President Trump seeking to outlaw medical sex-change alongside his crusade against abortion rights.
In essence, the imposition of binary gender identity places women back into the repressive primary status as baby-makers and feeds the power of the male-supremacists. It restricts what control each of us has over our own bodies, not just in how we appear but which of our feelings are legitimate.
Human biology is non-binary. As any biologist will admit, humans have a variety of chromosome classifications: XX, XY, XXY XXYY and all manner of variation which is why, in science, sex isn’t classified as binary. Genitalia at birth can be ambiguous. You can’t have a binary classification system when there are more than two configurations! That’s why Trans-women are women!
Transphobia is a threat to all of us seeking equality and the end to oppression. Look back at the laws and social attitudes against homosexuality in the 1960’s, now recognisable as extreme prejudice. The damning of those of us with gender dysphoria will once again be condemned in time.
In the meantime, this Supreme Court ruling has reduced Trans+ rights in the UK, Trans people now unable to make equal pay claims and excluded from single-sex spaces that confirm their true identity.
Luckily, Trans+ people, trade unionists and most of the socialist left have risen to immediate protest against the ruling with tens of thousands on the streets last Saturday. This debate isn’t over, the fight for universal human rights continues.

https://emotionalclimate.org/blog-feed/

Migrant Workers Give More than they Take

Tony StauntonLeave a comment

It becomes tiring and repetitive, but the point has to be continuously repeated – migrants and refugees are not the cause of the Age of Austerity – greedy bosses, their exploitation and oppression of the working class certainly is. And they’re organising to ensure it stays that way. My weekly Comment published in the daily Plymouth Herald (23.7.24) tried to explain at least some of the reasoning why we must say “Refugees are Welcome Here!”.

Keep them out! Last Thursday’s international summit, held at Winston Churchill’s ancestral home of Blenheim Palace, focussed upon the “threat” to Europe of from the East and the Global South. In short, the leaders of 14 countries determined they should collaborate to keep refugees out of Europe.

Of course, unlike the same policies in the USA, Europe cannot simply build a long, high and militarised wall to “keep’em out!”. The geography doesn’t allow for barricades. Instead, those seeking refuge will need to be turfed out, turned around, sent back, or imprisoned in regimes so inhuman as to act as a “deterrent” to peoples whose conditions are already inhuman. 

The leaders stood together to rightfully denounced the human traffickers, but focussed upon those arriving at Europe’s borders and Britain’s shores as “illegals”. Little or nothing was said about the reasons for this mass migration, or consideration of the causes rather than the effects upon their security, wealth and power.

The vast majority of people travelling northwards, in death-defying journeys of pain and fear, are escaping one of two never-ending horrors being experienced by those born in Africa and the Middle East. The first is the wars funded and armed by countries of the North, encouraged and applauded by the leaders dining at Blenheim Palace, producing extremes of wealth for the arms manufacturers and allied trades who pay the lobbying fees for their jamboree.

The second is the climate collapse engulfing entire regions of sub-Saharan Africa – some 46 countries – with tens of millions of humans marching away from their homelands, lands forever starved of water and arable land as a result of the fossil-fuelled emissions from the global North, heating the Planet towards mass extinction.

In these circumstances, humanity should be uniting to protect all. The opposite is the case. As if labelling human beings “illegal” isn’t inhuman enough, plotting to ensure they die “abroad” is despicable, outside of all the legal and moral tenets that are paraded at such grand political events.

Those of the far-Right reading this will be enraged. The white-supremacists and Capitalist entrepreneurs, driven by their quest for individual power and wealth, will be screaming at the page, arguing for a national pride that blames all Britain’s obvious social decline on Black people.

Refusing to consider the record profits and exemptions from paying tax that have seen wealth go from the poor to the rich at an accelerating rate through the past decade, they blame immigration for any and every social problem. 

The fuel bills that have tripled in 4 years have seen the oil and gas companies triple their profits into tens of thousands of millions of pounds paid for by us. The water & sewage bills that used to be covered by taxes as part of public services are now being raised whilst the owners harvest tens of billions of pounds from us, in profits. 

The low pay and long working hours culture that ensures at least 5 million of we, the working class, are reliant on top-ups from Universal Credit. 14 million of us live in subsistence poverty, including 4 million of our children, with 17 million homes requiring refurbishment. 

These numbers alone dwarf any cost to us attached to caring for refugees and asylum seekers. In fact, the tax money we pay towards subsiding the arms manufacturers and fossil fuel companies amounts to tens of billions pounds more than the costs of immigration. 

The skills shortages that are hiking costs in the service and construction industries could be solved by immigrant labour, but that solution is denied by the racist fanatics. Migrants allowed to work pay taxes, unlike the super-rich. It’s simple, working migrants produce taxes and fund commerce to a degree far higher than the initial costs of welcoming them here.

Stopping immigration will do nothing to stop the gross exploitation of working people here, will not reflate the Exchequer nor will it lower the bills. The politicians have let the racists off-the-leash and flagged migration as the key problem in order to create the cover for their continued profiteering and plundering of the public purse.

On Saturday, fascists and their racist allies are holding an anti-immigrant, white-supremacist march in London. Anti-fascists from across Britain will be joining forces to challenge their lies and hatred, supported by the national Trades Union Congress and dozens of trade unions. The rise of racism and fascism must be nipped in the bud before it swamps Britain and destroys the human rights we all require. 

Support the Students for Gaza!

Tony StauntonLeave a comment

My weekly Comment in the daily Plymouth Herald (28.6.24). This week, Ireland, Spain and Norway added their names to the growing list of countries demanding a Palestinian State. The backlash from the Israeli government supported by Biden and Sunak was disgusting, suggesting these countries are on the side of terrorists, as if the genocide being continued by Israel is not terrorism. 

You see, the trick is to accuse your enemy of precisely the crime you are committing. The deceit is formidable. To suggest that we who campaign for ceasefire, peace and freedom for Palestine are racist is quite a trick. The campaign  for Gaza has defeat of racism at its core.

Step, for four minutes, into our boots. 

Every Saturday for the past 7 months we have protested in Plymouth. Indeed, millions have combined into a single movement across the world across those months, to stop the genocide taking place in Palestine. 

We are approached by people with all sorts of views. Many offer support, some money for the Medical Aid to Palestine charity, much needed now every hospital in Gaza has been bombed and demolished. Some tell of us of their links.

And some come to attack us. Only a tiny minority offer such vitriol, the vast majority agreeing that the killing of Palestinian civilians has to stop. But they offer arguments for supporting the whole scale destruction of Gaza, the killing of 37,000 civilians including 12,000 children, the shooting and bombing that has caused over 80,000 casualties, and the preventing of food, clean water or fuel that is now causing the starvation of 1.5 million crammed into tented spaces amidst the rubble without any facilities. observers close to the ground are suggesting that over 100,000 have died, many of the bodies uncountable or unidentifiable and therefore unconfirmed.

It has become obvious that the far-Right in Plymouth, and Britain, and across the world, has rallied to the Israeli cause. The contradiction is historic. It was the far-Right fascist regime of Adolf Hitler and the National Socialists who perpetrated the Holocaust – the focussed and industrial organisation of extermination of more than six-and-a-half million Jews rounded-up from across Europe and systematically murdered in the cause of seeking racial purity and supremacy of the Aryan white-race, whoever they were invented to be.

Those protesting for Gaza today are the same people who have always challenged racism and fascism, exposing the horror of the Holocaust and demanding “Never Again”. We oppose antisemitism and organise to protect the rights of Jewish People alongside every other cultural and ethnic grouping. The right to follow a Faith has to be a fundamental human right.

However, the right to impose your religion on others has no basis at all. No-one can be forced to believe, only to pretend to follow a faith for survival’s sake. Only you can know what you truly believe. 

Consequently, creating a nation state where the belief in one religion endows you with rights and privileges denied to others must also be unacceptable. The Israeli State has developed a constitution and set of laws for a single ethnic group to be defined as citizens, and all others to be secondary with fewer rights. 

Students are revolting! Everywhere!

There are more than thirty encampments on university grounds across Britain, including in Exeter and Falmouth in our far South-West, mirroring many more in the USA and Europe. Their cause is simple – freedom for the people of Palestine.

The international demand for a permanent ceasefire in Gaza and for immediate aid and reparations for the millions of Palestinians experiencing deliberate and enforced starvation has majority support.

Yet, over the weekend, more Gazan civilians were killed and injured as Israeli troops bombed makeshift camps in Rafah, a refugee city on the very western edge of Palestine, bordering Egypt.

Nowhere to run, nowhere to hide, the people had been herded there in the first place at the barrel of a gun, told this was the safest place only to then be shot at and bombed from above.

There can be no excuse for this military offence. The actions of the Israeli Defence Force working to the orders of the Israeli government defy and break all international law on the conduct of war and treatment of displaced civilians.

The concerns of students and young people across the world should be heard. The International Criminal Court has demanded an immediate ceasefire, and issued an arrest warrant for the Israeli Prime Minister. The United Nations and International Court of Justice has identified acts of genocide    Continuing today. 

The UN says that 1200 Israelis and 37,000 Palestinian civilians have been killed including 16,000 children since October 7th last year. All hospitals in Gaza have been destroyed, and supplies of water and food prevented from reaching most, who have no shelter amidst the bombing of the entire region. 

Last week, Ireland, Spain and Norway added their names to the 137 countries recognising Palestine as a country and demanding the withdrawal of Israel’s occupying forces. Palestine has the right to exist, as it did before the creation of Israel in 1948 when terrorists invaded Palestinian land, shot and forced 750,000 inhabitants to leave their homes and become refugees. This Catastrophe, The Nakba, has been now repeated and amplified through 2024. 

Support for Gaza and freedom for Palestine represents a global cry for justice and human rights. Students are to the fore in taking action everywhere to stop this illegal war. It’s simple. If there is no justice for Palestine, there is no justice anywhere. 

Students campaign on many issues – for affordable and decent housing here, for access to food and medical care for children across Britain, for the right of all to education. For Peace, not war. These demands cannot be limited to Britain when billions of pounds of our taxes are being spent waging war and destruction on people elsewhere. We have to protest when our own educational establishments are making money out of genocide abroad.

Israel has bombed and flattened every university in the Palestinian Territories, yet most of our universities still invest in Israeli businesses and many have direct business dealings with the Israeli military. Our students have a simple demand – Stop Arming Israel! And one-by-one, universities are divesting from Israel, heeding their students’ moral demands. 

Trade unions, most of which have long supported Palestinian independence, must now act to support our youth. In Oxford, university authorities used Police to arrest peaceful protesters and uphold the university’s links with Israeli war crimes. Our response should be to defend the college encampments and demand a boycott of all military aid to Israel. 

When one country is allowed to enslave another, no-one can claim to be free. Permanent ceasefire now and Freedom for Palestine! Support our Students!

Shame of Enforced Extradition from UK

Tony StauntonLeave a comment

This week’s comment from me in the daily Plymouth Herald (23.4.24), hopefully timely in terms of this being the day when the Rwanda Bill becomes a law-defying law, and at least 6 people are drowned trying to reach Britain from France in small boats confronted by French coastguards. Until there is safe passage, there is no justice.

The law of forced extradition will come into play this week. In the next 12 weeks, a chosen handful, against their will and agency, may be taken to a place of departure by armed guards, and transported by plane to a country they have no links to and no rights within.

Rwanda has a recent record of human rights abuses. 

Five years ago the Rwandan police opened fire on refugees protesting. Rwandan security forces shot dead at least 12 refugees from the Democratic Republic of Congo when they protested against a cut to food rations.

Authorities arrested and prosecuted over 60 of them on charges including “spreading false information with intent to create a hostile international opinion against the Rwandan state”. These same laws could be used against the people Britain now wants to pluck from south coast beaches and dump in Africa.

On 15th January this year, documents sent to MPs by home secretary James Cleverly admitted that “While Rwanda is now a relatively peaceful country, there are nevertheless issues with its human rights record around political opposition to the current regime, dissent and free speech.”

Absurdly, Four Rwandan asylum seekers were granted refugee status in the UK last year over “well-founded” fears of persecution. Rwanda is not a safe refuge.

Indeed, polls posted by Al Jazeera show widespread concern inside Rwanda about the refugees and the Treaty with Britain. The Rwandan economy is in crisis, there is mass unemployment and no jobs, and a housing crisis similar to that of the UK. 

Rwanda has not implemented all the promises it made in the Treaty with the British State, which has so far cost the tax-payer £340million, with estimates of the numbers of refugees likely to be extradited reaching a cost of over £1,500,000 per person.

The new Act breaks many other laws governing law-making! It prevents courts from considering laws which protect human rights and the safety of individuals. It is a law of political imposition, overriding justice, that is the hallmark of a totalitarian state.

The only rational way to understand this despicable law is as a part of a wider intensification of the racist ‘hostile environment’, openly admitted to and quoted by the previous Home Secretary, Suella Braverman, who now criticises the Rwanda Act as too soft!

Given that the Rwanda Law makes no sense, it can only be understood as a racist law forced through by a racist government. It is an ideological pledge to a small core-group of ultra nationalist white supremacists who will salivate over the public execution of punishments for those seeking refuge. It is not the trafficking gangs who will be exposed or deposed. After all, we live in a Free Market economy which values and celebrates entrepreneurs!

Clearly, the racists want us to blame refugees for all the ills of Britain today. Whilst the far-Right criticise social conditions in Britain they do not support State intervention and taxation to eradicate poverty. They may also attack the Establishment’s intelligentsia, but they support unbridled Capitalism. This is why the scapegoating of “outsiders”, “The Other” is their primary target, their violent hatred as seen at various hostels and hotels focussed upon migrants they deem “illegal”.

Their dominant theme seeks to prevent and make invisible the real causes of the destruction of our country’s welfare state and infrastructure, which is causing misery for millions of UK citizens. 

The scale of deprivation and poverty here is far too great to be possibly caused by the numbers of asylum seekers arriving by flimsy boats or lorry chassis. 

The cost to the country of corrupt deals, tax-evasion by and unconscionable tax-handouts to the super-rich outweighs the cost of refuge 10,000,000-1. 

Shell and BP profits at over £40billion, paying less than 10% in tax despite the average worker here returning a total of nearly 40% of earnings in taxation. British Gas increased its surplus 10-fold whilst millions of us ration our heating due to fuel poverty. 

Tesco made £1.5billion profit from charging inflated prices for food whilst 2 million of us are reliant upon charitable food banks, 4 million UK children suffering poverty.

The water industries paid out £70bn to shareholders whilst overseeing degradation to a point of sewage pollution in every one of our rivers.

None of this is caused by refugees and asylum seekers, how could it be? None of these refugees are CEOs or shareholders. They have nothing. Yet the working class are told to blame and indeed hate them rather than the inhuman billionaires whose private wealth has increased by nearly 50% since 2020 by exploiting us. 

No human being can be deemed “illegal” – we are each subject to the lottery of being born somewhere unchosen. Only behaviours can be described as illegal according to law, and seeking to live isn’t a felony. Becoming super-rich off the backs of the poor is certainly a a crime, or should be.

The Rwanda Act must be repealed as part of a complete turn-around of our priorities and policies. Tax the Corporate Rich, put the welfare of all first and foremost, and ensure safe passage. Refugees are Welcome Here!

The Right To Strike is Worth Fighting For!

Tony StauntonLeave a comment

After a break, my weekly Comment published in the daily Plymouth Herald on 26th January 2024 offered an advert for the national demonstration called by Britain’s national trade union federation, the Trades Union Congress (TUC), on the following Saturday. There had been little advertising either inside the trade union movement or the national media, despite the issue. The government has passed new legislation effectively banning strike action. Public services, including education, transport and health care are subject to legal prosecution where any strike action does not maintain “minimum service levels, for example, 40% of train service or 80% of health care. It renders redundant the power of the strike action. What would be the point? This is easily the harshest anti-union law since the time of Margaret Thatcher in the 1980’s. Nevertheless, this has been the TUC’s only action on the issue. The demonstration widened a local demonstration originally called to commemorate the 40th anniversary of the campaign for recognition of trade unions at the GCHQ spy headquarters in Cheltenham (the most conservative and heavily vetted of all civil service staff), so that the national trade union bureaucracy could be seen to have “done something” whilst doing the least possible. In the end, over 5,000 activists marched proudly despite the poor organisation, and friendly reports also included the non-plussed but supportive comments of by-standers who couldn’t work out what the march was for. The spineless and weak response of the national leadership to this terrible attack on basic human rights should be a cause for outrage.

Tens of thousands of trade unionists will be marching in Cheltenham this Saturday. We are outraged. The cause should be of deep concern to all, even if hardly mentioned in the mainstream media. 

The UK’s Government for the Bosses has created a law that can force people to work against their will. The introduction of the Minimum Service Levels Act effectively undermines the “Right to Strike” – the right to withdraw our labour in collective pursuit of decent pay and treatment at work. 

Workers, such as train drivers or nurses, can be forced by law to go into work whilst being trade union members called into strike action. To defy the Law is to face immediate dismissal and potential prosecution.

To be forced into work is nothing less than slavery. More importantly, it is the end of the democratic human right be a member of trade union. 

After at least fifteen laws restricting and threatening trade union organisation made by successive Conservative governments from the 1980’s onwards, this is the most authoritarian and undemocratic of them all.

Little wonder that the Labour Party has promised to repeal the Act should it become the next government, but we are sceptical unless huge pressure is exhibited by mass protest from below – Blair and Brown did not repeal even one of Thatcher’s anti-union laws.

Indeed, Tony Blair boasted that Britain has the most strict employment laws limiting strike action anywhere across Western Europe. 

Nevertheless, in the wake of last year’s largest levels of strike action in 30 years, strikes continue.

Last week’s national strike by doctors was the longest in the history of the NHS, and more is planned. Doctors have lost over 25% of real pay in the last decade, the majority earning less than tradespeople. They are also profoundly angered by the dilapidation of the NHS they observe everyday.

Next week the train driver’s union, ASLEF, begins the next round of rail strikes, fighting not only for an inflation-rate of pay rise but also against plans for unsafe working conditions. Under this new law, the union is to be held responsible for ensuring a minimum 40% of services are maintained, neutering almost all impact of strike action. 

Teachers in schools and colleges are once again considering strike action, the conditions of our education system quite the worst in three generations. 

All these workers and more are identified by the new law and can be forced into work, all their collective power undermined by maintaining minimum services. Rather than protect the sick, the students’ quality of education or the travelling public, this new Law will simply create even more chaos and disruption. It has to be challenged and defied. 

The attacks on working class conditions and our right to collective organisation are being ramped-up in front of the General Election, asking the question, “which side are you on?”. 

What power have we as workers got, except to join together and stand in defiance of exploitation, oppression and injustice? The right to strike is immutable, and worth fighting for. 

The Trades Union Congress has called the demonstration in Cheltenham in recognition of the 40th Anniversary of the GCHQ strikes against the banning of trade union organisation in that government security agency. Workers were bribed into non-union status and those who refused, sacked. Their union rights were restored in 1997 after a long campaign. 

The lesson must be that we have to fight to win, not only by marching in our thousands on Saturday but taking the fight to the heart of government, by refusing to abide by this unjust law. 

Coaches from Plymouth are organised by the Unite trade union and others. Contact your union for a seat now, and join a union wherever you work.